Why Your Marketing Isn't Working (And What Actually Does)
When marketing budgets crack under pressure but fail to deliver ROI, it's time to diagnose what's actually broken.
The Frustration You Know Too Well
Your marketing isn't working. You've tried agencies, consultants, internal teams. The campaigns look professional, the metrics sound impressive, but your marketing not generating leads that actually convert. Your marketing ROI too low compared to what you're investing, and you're starting to question whether modern marketing even works anymore.
I've been there. Before scaling five brands globally and managing campaigns that generated over 1.5 billion fan engagements, I watched plenty of strategies fail. The difference wasn't talent or budget but was understanding why marketing fails in the first place, and what actually moves the needle when everything else stalls.
After over a decade in growth marketing, working with Formula E, managing €25M+ in campaigns and selling 250,000+ tickets, I've learned that most marketing problems aren't what they appear to be.
Why Marketing Actually Fails: The Root Causes Nobody Talks About
1. You're Solving the Wrong Problem
Most businesses think their brand not getting noticed because they need more exposure. That's rarely true. I've worked with brands that had massive reach but zero commercial impact. The real issue? They never defined what "noticed" actually means for their business model.
When a European motorsport series I worked with couldn't fill venues despite millions of social impressions, we discovered the problem wasn't awareness but was that their messaging attracted spectators, not ticket buyers. Same audience, completely different commercial outcome.
2. Launch Strategy Failed Because You Skipped Market Reality
Every launch strategy failed story I've encountered follows the same pattern: beautiful strategy documents that ignore how real people actually discover and adopt new things. I've seen companies spend six months perfecting positioning while their competitors captured market share with imperfect but immediate action.
One tech startup I worked with had been "preparing to launch" for eighteen months. We shifted focus from perfect positioning to rapid market feedback loops. Within 90 days, they had paying customers and real data about what actually resonated.
3. You're Measuring Marketing Like It's Advertising
The "why isn't my marketing working" question usually comes down to measurement problems. You're tracking impressions and clicks when you should be tracking behavior change and commercial outcomes. I learned this managing high stakes campaigns where "engagement" meant nothing if it didn't translate to race attendance or sponsor value.
A Different Approach: What Actually Drives Growth
Start With Commercial Outcomes, Work Backward
When businesses ask how to scale business faster, they usually want tactical advice. But scaling starts with clarity about what drives value in your specific business model. I approach every strategy by identifying the moment when awareness becomes commercial intent, then engineer everything backward from there.
For a global racing series, that moment wasn't when people knew about the sport but was when they understood how it connected to their personal interests. We stopped talking about racing technology and started talking about sustainability in motorsport. Attendance tripled because we connected to existing motivations instead of creating new ones.
Build Authority Through Demonstration, Not Declaration
The question of how to increase brand awareness assumes that awareness is the goal. It's not. Authority is. And authority comes from consistently demonstrating expertise through action, not messaging.
Instead of claiming innovation leadership, one client I worked with started publishing real-time race data that other series couldn't provide. Media outlets began citing them as the authority on racing analytics. Authority created awareness, not the other way around.
Test Market Realities Before Perfect Strategies
The fastest way to make brand stand out isn't perfect positioning but is rapid iteration based on real market feedback. I've seen brands transform their market position in months by testing assumptions quickly instead of planning endlessly.
We helped a consumer brand enter three different market segments simultaneously with minimal investment. Within 60 days, market response showed us which positioning had commercial traction. We concentrated resources there and gained significant market share while competitors were still researching.
Embed Growth Thinking Into Operations
When companies need help expanding internationally, they typically think about new markets as copying domestic success. That rarely works. International expansion requires embedding market specific insights into core operations, not just translating existing approaches.
For a global racing series expanding across European markets, we discovered that "global consistency" was actually limiting growth. Each market responded to different value propositions. We maintained brand consistency while adapting commercial messaging, resulting in 500% partnership growth across regions.
The Track Record Behind These Insights
These aren't theoretical approaches. Over the past decade, I've managed €25M+ in campaigns across 86 races, generating over 1.5 billion fan engagements and selling 250,000+ tickets. This work has consistently produced:
300% increases in global audience reach
500% sponsorship and partnership uplift
1,000% engagement growth across channels
More importantly, it's created sustainable growth systems. The European motorsport series I mentioned earlier continues growing without constant intervention because we built authority and market position, not just campaigns.
A tech startup went from industry unknown to category leader in 18 months using these principles. They didn't achieve this through massive marketing budgets or revolutionary products but consistently demonstrated market understanding through action while competitors made promises through messaging.
Your Next Step: The 48-Hour Market Reality Test
Here's what to test this week: Pick your strongest marketing claim about why customers choose you. Now find five potential customers who've never heard this claim and spend 15 minutes with each one discussing their actual decision-making process.
Budget: Zero. Time: 90 minutes total.
Ask them: "When you were looking for [your category], what made you choose [their current solution]?" Don't pitch but just listen. If your marketing claim doesn't naturally emerge from their answers, you've found your first assumption to test.
Most businesses discover their marketing messages focus on features that customers consider table stakes, while ignoring the emotional or practical triggers that actually drive decisions. Test this assumption first as it typically unlocks the biggest impact with the least effort.
Looking to experience Porter Wills for yourself? Let’s Talk
